Become a Fan

Your email address:


Powered by FeedBlitz

« Happy Endings | Main | Save the Children - And Save Yourself! »

January 28, 2009

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00e5520f87e0883301053587cfc4970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Outrageous! The Psychology of Self-Righteous Indignation:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

anom

thanks, i just had my self realization of self-righteousness and needed this

J. Sue Gagliardi

This is what I think of this article:

http://astrologizing.net/selfrighteousindignation.html

Anna Michael

Interesting

Monica

Thank you for this article. It has truely helped me to understand why someone has been making me feel like "crap" for several years. This article has really put a name to it for me, and to help me realize that I am not a bad person. Just an idiot for having put up with it for so long.

I

Hi Monica,

You're very welcome. Not an idiot, please. Nowhere are we taught the psychology of our interactions with others. So how could you know?

I'm pleased I could be of service.

JHW

Kellen,

How do you determine the difference between "self-righteous indignation" and just plain ol' vanilla "indignation"? Is it the sense of smugness and superiority? Where do you draw the line between "not my business/live and let live" vs. taking a stand in terms of values and morals when other people's actions/behavior are, well, "screwy" for want of a better term? Where do values and value judgements vs. ego come into play in this?

For example, a couple of years ago I was quite indignant for many months about how a friend's g.f. repeatedly took advantage of him. Now, he let her, and I said nothing to him after an initial discussion or two -- I thought it better to respect his decisions and stay out of it. I was angry at her for doing it and him for letting her, but in the end, I knew it was between them and not my business. I would still sometimes find myself angry on his behalf, but when my thoughts went in that direction, I reminded myself to keep out of it/"not my business", stayed silent, and kept my thoughts and feelings entirely to myself. I also made the decision not to listen if he wanted to complain about her, as he knew what he had by a certain point and he was participating/letting her take advantage of him, and he knew it.

They are now no longer together, and I am happy I made the choice I did (to keep my thoughts to myself). I was guilty of both self-righteous indignation and plain ol' indignation, and, if I had voiced them, it would have damaged the friendship over the long term.

What I found myself thinking during that situation, though, that I was reminded of by reading this post, is that on the one hand, I think that we shouldn't let ourselves by ruled by the "shoulds" -- "why shouldn't she and he do X,Y, or Z?" I would say to myself when I was getting self-righteous. On the other hand, sometimes you do have to take a stand in terms of values and morals....

Where do you draw that line, though, though, between "rightful indignation" and having a sense of morals and values, and "self-righteous indignation", where it seems to be about smugness and moral superiority? Where do you draw the line between having values and making judgements in the sense of evaluating right and wrong (a.k.a., "rightful indignation"), and value judgements that lead to self-righteous indignation and smugness?

In the example above, obviously your client needs to let go of her need to be right, but I can also see in some circumstances where she might need to stand up for her values. How do you determine what is acting on ego vs. what is acting based on your values and morals?

I'm just curious to hear your perspective as a therapist.

Thank you.

I

Hi JHW,

What interesting questions! Let me take a shot at the big one: self-righteous indigation vs. good 'ole healthy indignation.

In my humble opinion, the smugness and superior are the very purpose of self-righteous indignation. In fact, most people who are full of self-righteous indignation about something someone else is doing would often be very disappointed if they stopped doing it because they could no longer stand over them in judgement, feeling superior.

Indignation, by contrast, is truly concerned that something is wrong and seeks change. (And I totally agree with you that we must take a moral stand on things. Perhaps more than we do.)

I think these are the primary differences, but there is one additional factor that may be present. Not always, but sometimes. Self-righteous indignation always requires that someone else change their behavior.

Indignation is often followed by the person who is feeling it getting up and doing something about it. Isn't indignation the feeling which motivated Dr. Martin Luther King and Mahatma Ghandi?

So let's look at your very good example above (which you handled beautifully by the way). You were indignant that your friend was being used and had an intial discussion with him about it. When he didn't see it the way you did, you dropped it and walked away. As a loyal friend, you advised him of your concerns. When he chose to ignore you, you changed your behavior and respected his right to make the mistake. I don't hear you feeling smug or superior, just concerned for your friend and upset, because of your loyalty to him, that he was being used.

I believe that indignation seeks change without seeing other people as being morally inferior or "less than". The entire point of self-righteous indignation is to look down on someone else.

Indignation is about standing up for what we think is right. Self-righteous indignation is about putting someone else down.

What do you think?


Yogataylormade

Need to investigate what your characters are feeling to create authentic scenes, delve deep into character motivation to layer on emotional context within scene content.

Robert

Hi Ms Kellen,

How do I tell the people in my social circle and strangers that they are doing something wrong without being self righteous?

For example, if someone is sleeping late for two consecutive weeks and waking up early, and I want to tell he or she not to do that as it is unhealthy?


If I cannot say, you shouldn't sleep so late, then how do I say it?

Thank You.

Philoctotease

Guilty as charged. Thanks for a most helpful thread.

I'm living in a post Communist society that has a weakly functioning democracy, which I believe is directly related to their moral failings as a society (petty theft, corruption, total lack of trust). And my role as a language teacher often requires that I 'judge' others' work but a lot of the time their behavior as well. But I can't help seeing that their shortcomings as individuals, especially surrounding issues of trust, are precisely a result of those failures at the societal level. Moreover, the dysfunction begins in the home and is exacerbated by a poor educational system which focuses on rote learning rather than critical thinking. Therefore as one who was born to a fair amount of privilege and entitlement (to be brutally honest) and as the beneficiary of a solid college education, it's hard for me not to feel morally superior to them. And what is even more frustrating is that I'm totally cognizant of what I'm doing, but find it hard to change my behavior because, in my heart, I believe I'm trying to show them a better way. This stems from the belief of leading by action and not just words. Maybe I take my role as a teacher a little bit too seriously (maybe myself too).

Needless to say this behavior has consequences as I'm often classified as arrogant and foolish, and has cost me clients as a result more importantly.

And of course I do suffer from low self esteem and the other symptoms you identified previously, so there's no need in pointing that out.

But I would appreciate your thoughts. This has had a great impact on me emotionally.

Many thanks in advance.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Categories

Advertisements